| Platinum | Stefano's Pizza |
| Gold | Mama's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen |
| Silver | Mama Mia Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Peter Piper Pizza |
| Top Pick | Blue Onion |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pappa's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Scalisi's Chicago Pizza & More |
| Top Pick | Twin Peaks |